Is bleh a word? It conveys my feeling perfectly, so at least here on this blog, it’s a word for today.
I’m not going to say where I saw this recently, but it’s not an isolated incident. I was on a web forum for a beta book and it’s the sort of place where your title quite frankly does not matter. Not even your name matters. The whole point of this particular forum is helping the author finish a book that you find useful.
This particular person spent a whole lot of time explaining his credentials as a PhD and professor and blah, blah, blah about how he was qualified to make his comment and critique about a particular part of a BETA book. He went on to sign his name First Last, PhD.
What is it with these people?
Now, let me be perfectly clear that I’m not knocking PhD’s. I’m knocking the sort of people who sign every email with Dr, so and so, or Magna Cum Laude – Yale 1961 (it was 45 years ago for Pete’s sake, have you done anything interesting since then?). It’s a web forum! Nobody cares about your title. Your comment will count and get noticed if you actually have something interesting to say, not just because you signed it Blah Blah, PhD.
I think this set me off because in this case and in so many others, this person seemed to say “even though I’m a novice at this thing you’re writing about, and you’re the expert, my credentials in this other field give me special permission to say this particular thing about how you did this”.
Honestly, it would have been more effective to say, “Yo, Mr Author, I don’t get this part, would it work if you put this in here?”.
Says the same thing, less annoying and you don’t even have to spend $100K in school to make that comment.